“the area’s tradition of not interfering with the natural processes and the pace set by nature, while using in many cases techniques employed in biodynamic agriculture.”
Sandstone, clay and Pliocene limestone make up the soils of the undulating vineyards located from 650 to 735 meters; according to Wikipedia, back in the 1st century BC, the ancient Greeks taught the local Celtic tribes how to make wine, then In the Early Middle Ages, wines from Toro traded along the Duero river. Later, “wine producers built underground wineries (bodegas) in order to obtain better quality wines and to have more effective temperature control.”
During the phylloxera crisis in France and Spain in the 1870’s, local vines were protected by sandy soil so provided replacement wines and vines for other regions. The result is that Toro has many older vineyards of Tinta de Toro, an autochthonous or native/indigenous variety that is very similar genetically but looks and taste a little different from Tempranillo (much like Sangiovese is the grape grown in Brunello).
Of the wine and the region, Jancis Robinson says, “In the small, warmer but extremely fashionable Toro wine region to the north, the local, loose-bunched form of Tempranillo is known as Tinta de Toro. So far Toro wine has been made quite simply and is a sort of exuberant, turbo-charged fruity essence of Tempranillo. But sophisticated winemakers have been moving in and we can expect to see more subtle, longer-lived wines emerging.”
According to Wikipedia, “In 1990, the Junta de Castilla y León was involved in a clonal selection and vine sanitation plan, recovering and multiplying the autochthonous varieties of the Autonomous Community. Among these varieties is the Tinta de Toro, which is currently certified as an autochthonous variety, with its own name and well defined agronomous and ampelographic characteristics. It is commercialised under a blue label and its corresponding clone number.”
- 2016 – Matsu – El Picaro – 100% Tinta De Toro – 14.5% alcohol SRP $14
- 2015 – Matsu – El Recio – Tinta De Toro – 14.5% alcohol SRP $22
- 2015 – Matsu – El Viejo – 100% Tinto De Toro – 15% alcohol SRP $47
- Cheese plate:
Bay Blue from Point Reyes, Moliterno (pasteurized sheep’s milk, rennet, salt, black truffles), 12 month aged Manchego El Trigal, salt cured olives, spiced pecan.
- Filet mignon with rosemary
- Roasted potatoes and brussels sprouts with Spanish seasoning
Earlier in March, Gretel Meys Compton of Clos des Amis , Sue Hill of Cantara Cellars and Sue’s sweetie John came over for paella and Spanish wines, but while the whites, roses, red and sparkling wines I’ll be writing up soon went well with the paella, we weren’t satisfied with how these reds paired with the paella so the next night I paired them with filet mignon — much better! More tasting notes and pairing ideas below.
2016 – Matsu – El Picaro – 100% Tinta De Toro (Tempranillo) – 14.5% alcohol SRP $14
While we were tasting, we called this one “the young dude.”
Color: Reddish plum with a rose ring
Nose: Wicker, straw, cherry, cocoa nibs, forest floor, herbs, violets, black pepper
Palate: A lot of tannins, acids, tart cranberry, pomegranate, but especially rhubarb — when we came up with that descriptor, it was like hitting the head on the nose. Sarsaparilla on the finish.
This is not a cocktail wine. Bring this young dude to a dinner party and people will be impressed with his manners!
Pairing: I’d consider being a vegetarian if I could live on blue cheese and this wine. Sue felt it went nice with the aged manchego, but Gretel didn’t agree; we all thought it was great with ham or prosciutto. Wonderful with the filet mignon and roasted vegetables. This wine really opened up nicely over a few days.
2015 – Matsu – El Recio – Tinta De Toro – 14.5% alcohol SRP $22
While we were tasting, we called this one “the hot guy.”
Color: Very similar in color to the El Picaro, but it is more dense. In El Picaro you can see the bottom of the glass, but in El Recio it had a bit more of a coral ring; could be the one year age difference.
Nose: Peppery, herbs, menthol, chapparal, rosemary, sweet red dried fruit.
Palate: Front of the palate tart red fruit, forest, mesquite, beautiful finish, manzanita, sage and chaparral with the dryness of sage. John found incense cedar.
Pairing: It really likes the manchego cheeses especially the 18 month old manchego; my favorite of the three wines with the filet mignon. I’d love to try this with a rack of lamb. (P.S. My friends and I enjoyed sharing sunset with him in the desert!)
2015 – Matsu – El Viejo – 100% Tinto De Toro – 15% alcohol SRP $47
While we were tasting, we called this one the old guy.
These century old vines only produce a small amount of fruit meaning very limited production and grown using biodynamic techniques and aged for 16 months in oak.
Color: Denser than the El Recio, dense rich in color, plum, you cannot see the bottom of the glass easily.
Nose: Inviting and engaging red stone fruit, plum and cherry. slate, graphite, sage, pennyroyal, so much going on!!
Palate: Silky tannins, this wine is so very smooth, very nice roundness throughout the palate, nice bright cherry, the textural feel of this wine is so much more pleasant. Floral elements of carnation and rose plus black licorice mid palate throughout the finish. John got elements of cloves; I felt it was closer to clove oil.
Pairing: Very nice with strong blue cheese, excellent with the rosemary and filet mignon.
I shared the final glass of the old guy camping in the desert with a group of friends and a simple dinner of sausage at sunset. That was the moment when it was the best. Sigh. A taste was not enough! I’m glad I shared but I would have loved to have kept it to myself!
- Grateful for the samples of The El Picaro, El Recio and El Viejo ($13.99, $21.99 and $46.99 respectively); they are widely available through Monsieur Touton Selection.
- Time to toast the men and women that grow the grapes and get the finished wine to our tables!
- Happy Earth Month in April with biodynamic wines like these!
A great post, rich with history. El Recio seems like an ideal wine for steak or grilled burgers. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you! Tempranillo does pair really well with a range of meats, especially if they are grilled.
Great post and love the wine , especially el Viego!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you! Love these labels and this theme.